NZAU
Book a strategy call
SEO Strategy

Choosing a Search Partner in New Zealand: 12 Questions That Separate Operators From Order-Takers

Whether you're looking for the best SEO agency in Christchurch, a search partner in Wellington or a team in Auckland, the proposals tend to look the same. Everyone promises rankings, traffic and "a tailored strategy". The difference shows up in the answers to a few direct questions: who does the work, how results are reported, what it costs and what happens if it isn't working.

Here are the 12 questions we'd ask if we were hiring an agency, why each one matters, and our own answer to every one. Ask them of anyone you're considering, including us.

About the people

1. Who will actually do the work?

Why ask: Many agencies pitch with senior people and deliver with juniors. You want to meet the people who'll work on your account.

Our answer: Senior people. Our team is named on our team page, and the strategists you meet are the ones doing the work, with technology handling the heavy lifting so their time goes on thinking, not admin.

2. Do you work with businesses like ours?

Why ask: An agency that only knows one sector may struggle with yours. One that takes anyone may not be focused.

Our answer: Almost certainly, if the budget fits. Our Growth System works across industries; budget is the filter, not sector. The one exclusion is e-commerce, which we don't take on.

About results

3. What will you report, and how often?

Why ask: Reports full of impressions and rankings can hide the fact that nothing is reaching your sales team.

Our answer: A live dashboard that tracks leads, sales and revenue, plus a monthly review call. We report what the work earned, not how busy we were.

4. What should we expect at 90 days and at six months?

Why ask: Search compounds over time. An honest agency sets realistic milestones; a weak one promises page one in a month.

Our answer: Every engagement starts with a sequenced plan, so you'll know what happens in which month and what early signs of progress look like. We explain why the first 90 days matter in The First 90 Days Are Where Most Marketing Dies.

5. How will you benchmark us against competitors?

Why ask: Your rankings only mean something next to the businesses you compete with for the same buyers.

Our answer: Every programme starts with DigitalArchitect®, our proprietary analysis, as the first step of the Growth System. It shows where you sit against your competitors across search and AI answers, and it's included in every programme.

About search today

6. What's your approach to AI search?

Why ask: Buyers now find suppliers through Google, AI Overviews, ChatGPT and AI agents. An agency still working only on blue-link rankings is solving last decade's problem.

Our answer: We work across the full search stack: SEO, AI search and agentic search together, with Storyhouse, our creative team, producing the words, pictures and video. Our explainer on SEO, AEO, GEO and AIO covers how the pieces fit.

7. How do you handle local search?

Why ask: If you serve particular cities, your Google Business Profile, reviews and local pages matter as much as your website.

Our answer: Local search is part of the stack, from Google Business Profile and reviews to city pages. We have teams in Auckland, Christchurch and Wellington, and we work with businesses across New Zealand and Australia.

About money and commitment

8. What does it cost, all in?

Why ask: Hidden setup fees, extra charges for reporting and ad spend bundled into a retainer make proposals hard to compare.

Our answer: We publish indicative monthly fees for all three Growth System programmes on our programmes and pricing page. Paid media sits separately in our Brand Boost add-on, so you can see exactly what goes where.

9. Is it month to month, or are we locked in?

Why ask: Long contracts protect the agency, not you. If the work is good, you'll stay anyway.

Our answer: Month to month, with no lock-in contracts. The one exception is our website offer, which runs on a 12-month plan. You can change programmes at the monthly review.

10. What happens if it isn't working?

Why ask: Every plan needs adjusting. You want to know how problems get raised and fixed, not just how success gets reported.

Our answer: We review leads and sales with you every month and adjust the plan. If something isn't moving, we'll say so and change course. Because there's no lock-in, you're never stuck with something that isn't earning its keep.

About proof and ownership

11. Can we see results for businesses like ours?

Why ask: Case studies with named clients, real numbers and the people involved are harder to fake than testimonials.

Our answer: Our case studies name the client, the problem, the work and the result. Ask us for the ones closest to your situation.

12. What do we own at the end?

Why ask: Content, accounts, data and website code should belong to you, not stay with the agency if you leave.

Our answer: Ask every agency to put this in writing. When we build a website, you own the code, with no ongoing platform charges, and you can edit it yourself.

How to use these questions

Ask all 12 in your first conversation and take notes. Operators answer plainly and specifically, often before you've finished the question. Order-takers fall back on "it depends", "every client is different" or a promise of rankings. Pay attention to the questions an agency seems uncomfortable with. That's usually where the problems live.

If you want to compare agencies on the same footing, send the list to each one in writing before the meeting.

Ask who will do the work, how results are reported, what it costs all in, whether there's a lock-in, how they benchmark you against competitors and how they handle AI search. Compare the answers side by side.

Start with the 12 in this guide: who does the work, fit for your business, reporting, timelines, competitor benchmarking, AI search, local search, cost, contract terms, what happens if it isn't working, proof, and ownership.

It varies widely by scope. Ask for all-in monthly figures in writing. For reference, Growth Partners publishes indicative programme fees on its programmes and pricing page.

You don't need to. Month-to-month arrangements keep the agency accountable, and good work will keep you there anyway.

An SEO agency focuses on rankings. A growth agency runs marketing and sales as one system and is judged on leads and revenue. Our guide to growth agencies vs SEO agencies covers the difference.

Put us to the test

Bring these 12 questions to a strategy call. We'll answer every one, and show you where you sit against your competitors.

Book a strategy call

Trusted by teams at

Growth Partners clients include SiteMinder, MEX Engineering, Impact HR, SmartShelters, Hot Spring Spas, HR Profiling Solutions, Little Hotelier, Unistor, Storepro, Maple, GymQuip, Power Star Nutrition.